Badass (?): Reverend Adam Sylvaine, brawny yet contemplative Eversea cousin, discovering his vocation, serving the flock of Pennyroyal Green as their vicar while dodging the lustful and marriage-minded pursuits of the entire female population.
Falls For: Eve Duggan, widowed Countess of Wareham, notorious former Covent Garden actress, courtesan, and all-around Scandalous Woman.
Brought to You By: Julie Anne Long, in A Notorious Countess Confesses (2012) (7th in the Pennyroyal Green series)
Hangs Out In: The pulpit, the vicarage, and a certain bedchamber at Damask Manor.
Likes: Children and old people, sarcastic and scandalous old women in particular.
Dislikes: Anyone making snide, insinuating comments about Evie’s past.
Badass Hero Moment: When a man of the cloth throws a punch, or offers up five pounds he doesn’t have, you know it’s meaningful. Fortunately, he’s also forceful and persuasive from the pulpit. Definitely a winning combination.
Badass Annoying Moment: Makes snide — beyond insinuating — comments about Evie’s past. (At that point, though, they were both pretty much acting like idiots.)
(too) Frequently Described As: Golden.
(Richard Chamberlain, The Thorn Birds, 1983)
Ha ha. JAL has a clever bit of dialogue around the fact that Rev. Sylvaine doesn’t wear a “dress” (a cassock), and he’s (obviously) not a Catholic priest. He’s really more like a lanky, broad-shouldered country gentleman who happens to have the care of a church and its flock of parishioners rather in place of an estate. Still, the contrast between his outward control and inner lust, along with the inevitable loss of control and explosive sex reminded me of the infamous Father Ralph. Yes, I know Pennyroyal Green is a million miles from the Australian outback and really there’s nothing else similar about these two. But it made me smile to think about the Thorn Birds!
To Read Or Not To Read? So. The whole thing about Adam being a vicar really got me thinking, though, about what had to be different about him — from the other Eversea and Redmond males — in order to make him believable as both an alpha hero and a clergyman. I think both Adam and Evie were just kind of too… something… maybe it’s that they were both too earnest. It must have been a challenge to write him in such a way that he’d come across as a red-blooded…well… badass like his cousins Colin and Ian. These two, who we’ve already met and married off in prior books, make regular appearances here, checking up on Adam. It’s as if Long uses them to give Adam some badass glamour by association. I kept trying to figure out if he needed this kind of bucking up, or if he really is just a kind of beta badass, who keeps a low profile but is a force to be reckoned with when pushed to his limit.
What’s more convincing is Adam as a man exploring his calling as a caretaker of souls, even as a somewhat ambivalent sermon-writer and preacher. His humility as he discovers his gift and his vocation are nicely conveyed. But combined with the fact that Evie spends almost the entire book doing good works of one kind or another (she visits the parish poor, she makes huge and almost irrevocable sacrifices in order to provide for her own poor relations) there may have been too much humble pie for me.
That’s always part of the problem with a (former) courtesan heroine; there always have to be dire circumstances that forced her to sell herself, she has to be stoic and/or unapologetic about being a fallen woman, and she has to refuse to “drag down” the hero, before they can arrive at the HEA.
Bottom line — these two could not have made more incompatible career choices, and it just wasn’t quite as sparkling and fun — or even as funny — as the preceding Pennyroyals. I don’t know if I’m going to start giving letter grades, but if I had to, this would be a solid B. Anything from JAL is just so beautifully written and Pennyroyal Green is a place to which one wants to return again and again.
Tangentially Related … and Possibly Diverting: The setting in quaint PG, with the requisite assortment of odd and earnest villagers, at one point taking turns in a dramatic recitation of 1st Corinthians that is both sweet and ridiculous, also made me think about funny old Dibley.
Romance arrived for our dear Vicar of Dibley in the HILARIOUS episodes where Dawn French lusted after, and landed, smoldering Richard Armitage. Found this awesome video of Armitage and French romancing and goofing around together. I firmly believe any excuse to watch Richard Armitage should be taken advantage of, so Enjoy!
Who’s your favorite badass sexy preacher man? Can a clergyman be a convincing alpha hero?
Love your blog and so glad you are doing it. Well, I LOVE Ralph because he’s just so sexy and torn, but my favorite “man in black” that I love to hate is Soren in The Original Sinners . I mean that is one “badass” priest.
Thanks so much! So happy you dropped by to check it out! Now I need to go look up The Original Sinners….! I agree that something about a hero in holy orders really intensifies the theme of the strong man who’s torn in two by conflict/conscience. Of course in a romance novel (unlike The Thorn Birds) it wouldn’t work for the clergyman in question to have vows of celibacy, because there has to be a happy ending with a wedding. It works in a Regency historical because he can be an Anglican priest (and actually EXPECTED to marry). But somehow being a vicar is much more of a tough sell as a badass!
I’m not sure The Original Sinners would qualify as a Romance, then. It’s more in line of 40 Shades of Grey, only more BAD and sinister and shocking!!! It’s a series,which hasn’t ended yet. You do need to check in out, though!
I agree with you that this was less of a romp than some of the other Pennyroyal Green books, but I have adored them all. I think my favorite part of this book was the embroidered pillows from the hopeful parishioners.
Wasn’t one of Gaffney’s Wyckerly books about a vicar?
It’s To Love and to Cherish – I haven’t read it (or any of this series) but looks like it’s about to be reissued in June. I am putting it on my TBR list! This sentence from the publisher’s blurb on Amazon is making me laugh because it could be describing Adam:
“And with his golden-haired good looks and palpable strength, Christian “Christy” Morrell has unexpectedly become the single source of light in Anne Verlaine’s dark life. ”
I am going to be especially interested to see if Gaffney can make a vicar a convincing alpha badass, if indeed he is meant to be an alpha hero.
[…] or any of her other romances. I first thought about reading To Love and To Cherish when I posted a review of Julie Anne Long’s Pennyroyal Green romance with a vicar for a hero (A Notorious Countess […]
[…] Pennyroyal Preacher Man – another early review-ish post, that ended up steering me towards the challenging novels of Patricia Gaffney, and related discussions […]
[…] felt moved to do a post about this book, except as it comes up tangentially when people talk about romance novels with clergy heroes. Sitting in traffic listening to the NPR obituary I had a random thought about how it would be […]